A tasting in three parts. It is impossible to gather everyone on the same night, so the groups are split thus:
29/01/2026: kruuk2, ruckus, JS, tOMoH
22/02/2026: Psycho, adc, ydc, GD, tOMoH (JS joins briefly)
23/02/2026: Bishlouk, red71, STL, sonicvince, dom666, GN, tOMoH (Psycho joins briefly)
The below is a synthesis of those nights. All drams are poured blind.
Dram #1
Mouth: an old man's whisky (ruckus) -- and, indeed, it is toffee and old cardboard, which supports kruuk2's comment that "it tastes like whisky". "I like it, it's a perfect day for this" (adc). Psycho says it is lightly woody, with dry wood and spices (Psycho), whereas GD has pepper and finds this sticks to the gob. Bishlouk sees a classic Speyside palate.
Finish: "whisky as it is traditionally understood" (kruuk2), "the kind of drams one drinks with one's cocker spaniel by the fireplace" (kruuk2). A light aniseed touch and honey (ydc), a tad nondescript (Psycho) and spicy again (GD). sonicvince spots coffee beans where Bishlouk has a slight astringency. He adds it is a tad vegetal, but a classic Bourbon cask nonetheless.
Comment: a few timid guesses, none a blend. adc is reminded of that Isle of Jura, calls it light as a Lowlander, yet characterful as an Islay. My notes are here.
Sandy Macnab’s Old Blended Scotch 5yo (40%, Macnab Distilleries, b.1980s)
STL: "GN just confirmed he is part of the same family!"
Mouth: kruuk2 declares that the Haribo sweets are lost, while ruckus utters a simple "50%?" (spot on). GD calls it explosive and buttery, when ydc identifies quince and peach. Dry upon entry (Bishlouk), STL soon says it has balls and operates a noticeable shift in horsepower. Beyond that, it is woodier (Bishlouk) and offers rancio (Bishlouk). STL also finds it spicier, once his taste buds are accustomed to the brute force.
Finish: kruuk2 wonders if it is a grain. adc finds it "not bad," even if she is not taken by the first gulp. She acknowledges that one needs to go to it and the more she tries it, the more she likes it. When red71 calls a bitter touch, GN specifies ashes.
Comment: even after the reveal, ruckus and kruuk2 struggle to recognise the distillery markers. This makes GN think of Balcones Brimstone. My notes are here.
Lochside 21yo d.1981 (50%, Lombard Jewels of Scotland, Bourbon Cask, C#607)
tOMoH: "She will be working. Not you."
dom666: "No, I'm giving her..."
GN: "Money!"
(The above is, of course, to tease dom666, not to make a sweeping comment about Lithuanians.)
Dram #3
Mouth: ruckus finds it more interesting in the mouth (a phrasing that Bishlouk would undoubtedly latch on to, were he there on the same night). adc is not taken by the first sip of this one either. Psycho finds cough drops, while ydc has subtle berries -- perhaps strawberries. She says it is hard to pinpoint, but then starts talking about Fraises Tagada. "Indescribable," says Bishlouk, who says it shoots stuff in all directions. sonicvince reckons it is too syrupy to be a Littlemill. dom666 announces lychee.
Finish: kruuk2's favourite so far, and ruckus likes it too. Hay (adc), bison herb (adc), grasses (adc). It is warming (GD) with a very-long finish (Psycho).
Comment: once revealed, ruckus and kruuk2 acknowledge the fruity Irish profile. adc, after a lukewarm welcome, loves it. On the third night, many ask me to order them a bottle of this, if available, with sonicvince calling it one of the best whiskies he has ever tried. Tough luck finding one. GN liked the first two drams more, on the other hand. My notes are here.
Midleton d.2014 (unknown ABV, Duty Paid Samples, Double Charred Bourbon Cask)
Psycho: "The strawberries of horses."
Dram #4
Mouth: ruckus notes that it punches pretty hard. GD spots chilli (he is easily affected by spices, it seems) where ydc has torrefied cocoa and coffee beans. She also has caramel and a whisper of ginger (which adc has too). Psycho calls it acidic and pungent. When GD mentions light soy sauce, Psycho counters with dark soy sauce. Far from that, Bishlouk notes vanilla and spices. GN continues his biscuit trip with Palets Bretons, which are a local type of shortbread.
Finish: dry, with a note of coffee (kruuk2). ruckus and kruuk2 settle on Mokatine, which is pretty accurate a descriptor. adc finds it a fleeting note that works less well -- she calls it a bit rough. ydc talks about acetone. "The taste is fleeting," says sonicvince who is left with but the tingle of alcohol, although he says it retains a buttery side too.
Comment: JS likes this a lot. sonicvince finds it formidable, meaning enjoyable and indomitable. My notes are here.
Glenallachie 14yo 2000/2014 (57.3%, Chivas Brothers Cask Strength Edition, B#GA 14 006)
Dram #5
Mouth: some spices here too (ruckus), industrial (kruuk2), engine grease (ruckus), a server room (kruuk2), an old computer whose fan is full of dust (kruuk2). Psycho finds it characterful and very good. ydc calls it very aromatic. For sonicvince, this is salty on the tongue, or peppery, according to red71, who adds that the nose and the palate are disconnected, as if they belonged to two completely separate whiskies.
Finish: in the medium run, alcohol blows up in one's face (kruuk2). ruckus finds it even dustier and more industrial in the empty glass. "The tip of the tongue spots Highland-cow dung" (adc). ydc is "all warm inside" and says this "unpots" (meaning it kicks so hard that one is thrown out of one's pot -- if one is a plant). Psycho agrees to the warming adjective and GD notes that this too sticks to the gob. red71 finds that it stings. He and Bishlouk observe a deluge of black pepper.
Comment: it is a smidge brutal, of course, but what a dram! This is less adc's thing, tonight. It is universally recognised as a whisky that punches on in the face. My notes are here.
57.4 15yo 1979/1994 (63.1%, SMWS Society Cask)
STL: "To get her residence permit!"
Dram of the day:
- ruckus: Midleton
- kruuk2: Midleton
- JS: Glenallachie
- adc: Sandy MacNab, Midleton
- ydc: Glenallachie, Lochside, Glen Mhor, Sandy MacNab, Midleton
- GD: Midleton
- Psycho: Lochside, Glen Mhor
- STL: Midleton
- Bishlouk: Midleton
- sonicvince: Midleton
- red71: Midleton
- GN: Lochside
- dom666: we will never know
No comments:
Post a Comment